Skip to content

Should working class students boycott university?

November 4, 2009

I went to university to arrest my spiraling, downward mobility and remedy my chronic ignorance. It was the mid-90s, I was in my mid-20s and the student grant hadn’t yet been abolished, so university was a realistic option for a prospective student from a working class background who didn’t have clue what he wanted to do with the rest of his life. Today I still don’t know what I want to do with the rest of my life but at least I’ve an arse in my trousers (as my Granny would say) and I’m less ignorant than I was before university admissions in 1994. That said, were I ignorant and poor today I can categorically say I would not look to university to improve my circumstances. In fact, I’ve had a thought so heretical that I blush to think of it: should working class students boycott university?

Even though I’m both a beneficiary and (in principle) a supporter of widening access to university, I can see that successive governments have handled the extension of higher education badly and their motives are suspect. Swelling student numbers has not been met with a commensurate increase in staff and resources, and this has, of course, had a detrimental effect on the quality of the education provided in HE. It is also an indication that the arrival of students from non-traditional backgrounds (in the jargon) has announced a fundamental change in the experience and role of universities. Institutions that once produced the ruling class are today full of riff-raff like me and that changes everything.

The previous Conservative administration saw in universities a away of massaging the unemployment figures but New Labour has grander plans and reckons higher education can engineer economic prosperity and facilitate greater social mobility. To achieve this it has made higher education subservient to business and encouraged students to behave like consumers, neither of which has done anything for the intellectual life of universities.

According to Clare Fox, marketisation has ‘turned education on its head’. Writing in the Macdonaldisation of Higher Education, she points out the fundamental change in tutor/student relations.

Students are no longer supplicants who must demonstrate that they deserve to be accepted as apprentices by the most advanced minds and researchers in the field. Rather students are the masters that must be flattered and cajoled by humble lecturers who are warned that students will take their “custom” to other educational institutions if they are not satisfied with the marked they receive or the way they are taught.

Asserting the authority of teachers isn’t very cool these days but it is undeniable that lecturers know better than their students. Consumers are always right but students can’t be. Students by definition should be seeking enlightenment, so to stand the student/lecturer relationship on its head is to disregard expertise, knowledge and learning, and replace it with the unending quest for the Holy Grail of value for money. Government and university Vice-Chancellors seem sanguine about this but it means that universities may carry the name ‘higher education’ but none of the substance .

The key to facilitating this lamentable state of affairs is fees, which have not only turned students into consumers but landed them in extraordinary debt. Students who started university in 2007 are likely to owe more than £17, 500, according to the BBC last year, and pressure is growing for fees to rise further.

I can’t help but suspect that there is more to student loans than paying for an education. According to Ben Funnell debt is ‘capitalism’s dirty little secret’: Writing the wake of the credit crunch in the Financial Times in June 2009  ‘excessive lending was the only way to maintain the living standards of the vast bulk of the population at a time when wealth was being concentrated in the hands of an elite.’ So, that’s why young people are saddled with such debt even before they start their working lives, to keep the rich in the style they have become accustomed to.

But the genius of the system doesn’t stop there. If you are a student from a working class background that has got yourself in hock to pay for a higher education of dubious value, don’t expect access to any of the leading professions. A recent government report published on 21 July 2009 suggests that careers in law, medicine, teaching and journalism are often closed to students from working-class backgrounds. And it’s not the only report grappling with how and why working class students are disadvantaged in the graduate labour market.

According to education expert, Prof Alison Wolf, we’ve reached the stage where universities are producing far more graduates than the labour force can provide for. And study after study shows that the number of ‘over-qualified’ workers has been increasing because as the number of graduates increase so does the number of ‘graduate’ jobs – jobs that in truth require no more qualifications and skills than they did when performed by non-graduates.

So, crap, intellectually vacuous courses, massive debt and a job at the end of it all that previously asked only for clean drivers license but now demands a degree. It’s hard not to conclude that there is something rotten about the wedding of education to economic imperatives, which is why I’m wondering should working class students boycott university?

9 Comments leave one →
  1. Upper permalink
    November 9, 2009 5:22 pm

    LOLOLOLOL…. Yep the working class should not be in UNI.

  2. November 11, 2009 3:19 pm

    Yep … study to just get into debt.Oh no!Crap!

  3. November 24, 2009 10:47 pm

    I agree 100% with your analysis, it is spot on. I don’t agree with the conclusion that tempts you. You might get a better job with a degree, you might not. However, if the value of a degree is falling, then working class people would be disadvantaging themselves against middle class kids who still manage to get a degree, despite a remarkable lack of interest in what they study, in a job market that asks for graduates.

    However, this just confines us to the narrow justifications of education that we are being offered at the moment. What you are discounting is that, despite the crap that is being dished up, higher education can be life-enhancing, inspiring and empowering. And the debt issue is only the case if you go full-time. If you are low paid or on benefit you can get a part-time degree for free.

    We need to open the doors wider and force the imaginative reforms that will include more working class people and transform higher education.

    Thus far academics have only moaned about the university, the point is to change it!

  4. Rabelais permalink*
    November 25, 2009 10:06 am

    Hi Peter,
    I’m not sure I agree with my conclusion either. And just to clarify, I’m only ‘wondering’ about it…

    If students organised a boycott of universities on the basis that they are being ripped off, I’d support it. I doubt that will ever happen so I think the road to travel is as you suggest: academics should stop moaning about the sate of HE and do something about it.

  5. CharlieMcmenamin permalink
    December 14, 2009 9:13 pm

    Or just set up their own university?

    Naw, the Trustafarians would just take it over I reckon….

  6. June 1, 2010 12:48 am

    I’m wondering whether everyone should boycott university and find some other way of acquiring knowledge and skills…

  7. Rabelais permalink*
    June 2, 2010 9:09 am

    I think people do.

    It’s very hard to suppress some people’s curiosity.

  8. Chris permalink
    February 5, 2013 1:26 pm

    The first paragraph describes me exactly. I’m hitting forty and i’m in an entry level job I could have got with a £200 certification, except I’m saddled with £10,000 of degree debt. I have noticed on Linkedin, that the well-off kids from uni are now in well-paid jobs. I’m wiser now. I’ve been window licking the glass ceiling for long enough. Of course we should boycott university!

  9. Rab permalink*
    February 5, 2013 6:05 pm

    Welcome Chris,
    I have a hunch there are many in a similar situation and I there will be even more given the state of the economy.

    I loved university because I liked learning but these days I’m sceptical about the claims being made linking university to employment opportunities. I remember when I first graduated and was looking for work. I had a first class degree but I was being offered exactly the sort of work that was available to me before I graduated.

    I hope things improve for you. Good luck.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: